Larger Thought Unit
The larger section of the two great commandments of the Law should also include the following story of Martha and Mary. Note that the parable of the Good Samaritan occurs only in Luke and is in response not to the question of “what is the greatest commandment” but rather “what shall I do to inherit eternal life?” It is important in today’s reading to see the importance of the question of ‘who’ is my neighbor, as this was understood differently within nascent Judaism, who generally rejected Samaritans and Gentiles in their definition. The ‘shock’ value of this parable as well cannot be underestimated in making a Samaritan the hero and fulfiller of the Law and thus the one who is part of God’s people and the inheritor of eternal life, as opposed to the very technically strict ‘law-abiding’ priest and Levite. Note that this is followed by the story of Martha and Mary where the issue is discipleship, i.e., loving Christ and being taught by him as the fulfillment of the greatest commandment of loving God.
Notes
Just as Paul’s argument runs in Romans—the Jews have the Law but, because they do not practice it, it condemns them (Rom 2)—here too in this parable a νομικός (a Jew who is expert in the Mosaic Law) trying to put Jesus to the test, ends up being put to the test himself. He is shown that, as Paul teaches in Rom 2:26-27 (So, if a man who is uncircumcised keeps the precepts of the law, will not his uncircumcision be regarded as circumcision? Then those who are physically uncircumcised but keep the law will condemn you who have the written code and circumcision but break the law), a Samaritan (with whom the Jews had no dealings; Jn 4:9) takes care of a complete stranger, whereas a priest and a Levite, going down from Jerusalem, where supposedly they have fulfilled God’s will, in fact end up contravening it, since God’s entire Law is subsumed in the love for the neighbor (Gal 5:14; Rom 13:9). The Samaritan lives up to the gospel of mercy (Lk 10:37), and the Jewish νομικός is invited to “do” likewise.
Further resource
Charles H. Talbert, Reading Luke, Smith & Helwys Publishing, Macon, GA, 2002; pp. 127-132.
Paul Nadim Tarazi, New Testament Introduction, Vol.2: Luke and Acts, St Vladimir’s Seminary Press, Crestwood, NY, 2001; pp.88-89.